Polity Set 72
🔍
📌 Panchayati Raj • Committees
Q.1) The Balwant Rai Mehta Committee, appointed in 1957, recommended the establishment of a:
Ans > Three-tier Panchayati Raj system
- Background and Core Purpose: The Government appointed the Balwant Rai Mehta Committee in January 1957 to examine the Community Development Programme (1952) and the National Extension Service (1953) to ensure public participation.
- Birth of Democratic Decentralization: Submitted in Nov 1957, the report coined the term “democratic decentralization,” which became known as the ‘Panchayati Raj’ system.
- The Proposed Three-Tier Structure: Recommended a linked three-tier system: Gram Panchayat (village), Panchayat Samiti (block), and Zila Parishad (district).
- Distribution of Executive Powers: Suggested the Panchayat Samiti be the primary executive body, while the Zila Parishad function as an advisory and supervisory body.
📌 Panchayati Raj • Historical Implementation
Q.2) Which state was the first to establish Panchayati Raj (on October 2, 1959, in Nagaur district) following the Balwant Rai Mehta Committee report?
Ans > Rajasthan
- The Historic Inauguration: Rajasthan holds the distinction of being the first Indian state to formally implement the Panchayati Raj system in the Nagaur district.
- Symbolic Date Selection: Launched on October 2, 1959, honoring Mahatma Gandhi’s birth anniversary and his vision of “Gram Swaraj” (village self-governance).
- Prime Ministerial Involvement: Inaugurated personally by India’s first Prime Minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, highlighting its national importance.
- Subsequent Adoptions: Andhra Pradesh became the second state to adopt it later in 1959, followed by most major states by the mid-1960s.
📌 Panchayati Raj • Committees
Q.3) The Ashok Mehta Committee, appointed by the Janata Government in 1977, recommended replacing the three-tier system with a:
Ans > Two-tier system
- Political Context: Constituted in December 1977 by the Janata Party government to revive and strengthen the declining Panchayati Raj system.
- The Two-Tier Proposal: The 1978 report recommended scrapping the three-tier structure for a two-tier system: Zila Parishad at the district level and a Mandal Panchayat at the base.
- Shift in Executive Authority: Proposed the Zila Parishad as the primary executive body, arguing the district was a more viable unit for planning and executing programs.
- Political Participation and Taxation: Suggested open participation of political parties in elections and granting compulsory taxation powers to PRIs.
📌 Panchayati Raj • Committees
Q.4) Which committee was appointed by the Rajiv Gandhi government in 1986 on the ‘Revitalisation of Panchayati Raj Institutions for Democracy and Development’?
Ans > L.M. Singhvi Committee
- Mandate for Revitalization: Established in 1986 under PM Rajiv Gandhi to find ways to revitalize PRIs as effective instruments for local democracy.
- Demand for Constitutional Status: The committee’s most significant contribution was recommending constitutional recognition to protect local bodies from state interference.
- Emphasis on Gram Sabha: Placed immense importance on the Gram Sabha, calling it the “embodiment of direct democracy.”
- Reorganization & Justice: Recommended reorganizing villages for viability and establishing Nyaya Panchayats (village courts) for swift rural justice.
📌 Constitution • 73rd Amendment
Q.5) The 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act of 1992 added a new Part to the Constitution titled “The Panchayats”. Which Part is it?
Ans > Part IX
- Historical Legislative Journey: Passed during P.V. Narasimha Rao’s tenure in 1992 after earlier attempts by Rajiv Gandhi and V.P. Singh failed.
- Structure of Part IX: Inserted Part IX titled “The Panchayats,” containing a comprehensive framework spanning Articles 243 to 243-O.
- Date of Enforcement: Came into force on April 24, 1993, now celebrated annually as “National Panchayati Raj Day.”
- Transition to Mandatory Governance: Transformed village panchayats from a mere Directive Principle (Article 40) into a legally binding constitutional mandate.
📌 Constitution • Schedules
Q.6) The 73rd Amendment Act also added the Eleventh Schedule to the Constitution. How many functional items of the panchayats are listed in it?
Ans > 29
- Constitutional Linkage: The Eleventh Schedule is directly linked to Article 243G, detailing powers and responsibilities devolved to Panchayats.
- Scope of Items: Lists 29 functional subjects vital for local economic development, from agriculture and electrification to primary education.
- Focus on Social Welfare: Emphasizes welfare of weaker sections (SCs/STs), family welfare, women and child development, and public distribution systems.
- Discretionary Devolution: State Legislatures have discretionary power to decide which of these 29 subjects are actually transferred to the local bodies.
📌 Panchayati Raj • Gram Sabha
Q.7) Which Article forms the foundation of the Panchayati Raj system by establishing the Gram Sabha?
Ans > Article 243A
- Definition: The Gram Sabha consists of all persons registered in the electoral rolls within the village area. It is the only permanent body in the PRI system.
- Direct Democracy: Article 243A establishes the Gram Sabha as the foundational tier, embodying direct democracy where citizens assemble to discuss issues.
- Powers Determined by State: The exact powers and functions are left flexible for the State Legislature to define by law.
- Accountability Role: Serves as a watchdog, reviewing annual accounts, approving plans, and identifying beneficiaries for welfare schemes.
📌 Panchayati Raj • Structure
Q.8) Article 243B provides for a three-tier system of panchayats. A state having a population not exceeding what number may not constitute panchayats at the intermediate level?
Ans > 20 lakhs
- Mandate for Uniformity: Article 243B aimed to bring structural uniformity, mandating a standard three-tier system (village, intermediate, district) across India.
- The 20 Lakh Exemption: States with a total population of less than 20 lakhs (2 million) are granted constitutional liberty to bypass the intermediate level.
- Rationale: Prevents administrative bloat and financial strain on smaller states (like Goa, Sikkim) where a middle tier is demographically redundant.
- Intermediate Level: Commonly known as Panchayat Samiti or Mandal Parishad, this tier sits between the village and district levels.
📌 Panchayati Raj • Elections
Q.9) All members of panchayats at the village, intermediate, and district levels shall be elected:
Ans > Directly by the people
- Direct Democracy Mandate: Article 243C strictly mandates that all members filling seats at every level must be chosen by direct election by citizens.
- Exception for Chairpersons: Chairpersons at the intermediate and district levels are required to be elected indirectly by and from amongst the elected members.
- State Discretion for Village Chairperson: The state legislature decides whether the Gram Panchayat Chairperson (Sarpanch) is elected directly or indirectly.
- Ex-officio Members: State legislatures may include local MLAs and MPs as ex-officio members with voting rights in higher-tier panchayats.
📌 Panchayati Raj • Reservation
Q.10) Article 243D provides for the reservation of seats for SCs and STs. It also mandates that not less than what fraction of the total number of seats shall be reserved for women?
Ans > One-third
- Proportional Representation: Article 243D ensures SCs and STs receive reserved seats mathematically tied to the proportion of their population in the panchayat area.
- Women’s Empowerment: Explicitly mandates a minimum of one-third (33.33%) of total seats to be filled by direct election must be reserved for women.
- Intersectional Reservation: One-third of the seats specifically reserved for SCs and STs must also be exclusively allotted to women from those communities.
- States Exceeding Mandate: States like Bihar, MP, Kerala, and West Bengal have proactively increased women’s reservation to 50%.
📌 Panchayati Raj • Tenure
Q.11) The duration of every panchayat is fixed at five years. If it is dissolved before the expiry of its term, elections must be held within:
Ans > Six months
- Guarantee of Fixed Tenure: Article 243E cured frequent state suspensions by guaranteeing a strict five-year term calculated from the first meeting.
- Strict Election Deadlines: If prematurely dissolved, the state is legally bound to hold fresh elections within a maximum window of six months.
- Remainder of Term Rule: A reconstituted Panchayat continues only for the remainder of the original five-year period, not a fresh five years.
- Near-Term Expiry Exemption: If the remainder of the period is less than six months, holding elections to reconstitute the body is not necessary.
📌 Panchayati Raj • Qualifications
Q.12) To be disqualified from being chosen as a member of a panchayat on the ground of age, a person must be less than:
Ans > 21 years
- Lowering the Threshold: Article 243F establishes the minimum age for contesting Panchayat elections at 21, lower than the 25 years required for MLA or MP elections.
- Encouraging Youth: Intended to inject young voices into grassroots administration and foster early political leadership.
- Uniformity with State Laws: Persons are also disqualified if they violate any standard election law made by the state legislature.
- Adjudication of Disputes: Civil courts are prohibited from interfering; disputes are referred to authorities appointed by the State Legislature.
📌 Panchayati Raj • State Election Commission
Q.13) Article 243K deals with elections to the panchayats. The superintendence, direction, and control of these elections shall be vested in a:
Ans > State Election Commission
- Independent Authority: Article 243K mandated an independent State Election Commission (SEC) separate from the national Election Commission to prevent state manipulation.
- Commissioner Appointment: The SEC is spearheaded by a State Election Commissioner appointed directly by the Governor.
- Safeguards for Independence: The Commissioner can only be removed in the exact same manner and on the exact same grounds as a High Court Judge.
- Conditions of Service: Their service conditions cannot be varied to their disadvantage after appointment, ensuring financial and administrative protection.
📌 Panchayati Raj • Finance
Q.14) Article 243-I states that the Governor shall constitute a State Finance Commission to review the financial position of the panchayats every:
Ans > 5 years
- Institutionalizing Financial Autonomy: Article 243-I mandates the Governor to constitute a State Finance Commission (SFC) every 5 years to objectively review local body finances.
- Tax Distribution: The SFC formulates principles for the equitable distribution of state taxes, duties, and tolls between the State and Panchayats.
- Grants and Taxation: It recommends which taxes may be assigned to Panchayats and sets criteria for grants-in-aid from the State Consolidated Fund.
- Central Integration: The Central Finance Commission uses SFC recommendations to augment the State Consolidated Fund to further support PRIs.
📌 Panchayati Raj • Exemptions
Q.15) The provisions of Part IX (Panchayats) do not apply to certain states, including:
Ans > Nagaland, Meghalaya and Mizoram
- Protection of Indigenous Systems: Article 243M exempts Nagaland, Meghalaya, and Mizoram because they possess entrenched, traditional tribal council systems.
- Schedule VI Exemption: Also exempts specific tribal areas in Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura, and Mizoram governed under the Sixth Schedule (autonomous district councils).
- Hill Areas: The hill areas of Manipur and the Darjeeling Gorkha Hill Council in West Bengal are also exempted to respect regional autonomy.
- Parliamentary Override: Parliament holds the authority to extend Part IX to these exempted areas by passing a specific law with modifications.
📌 Panchayati Raj • PESA Act
Q.16) To extend the provisions of Part IX to the Scheduled Areas with certain modifications, the Parliament enacted the PESA Act in the year:
Ans > 1996
- Bridging the Gap: Parliament enacted the Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) Act (PESA) in 1996 to bring decentralization to Fifth Schedule Areas while respecting tribal customs.
- Bhuria Committee: Drafted based on the Dileep Singh Bhuria Committee recommendations, integrating formal frameworks with traditional community living.
- Supreme Gram Sabha: PESA elevates the Gram Sabha to supreme authority in these areas, competent to safeguard customs and cultural identity.
- Resource Control: Grants sweeping powers over land acquisition consultation, ownership of minor forest produce, and control over local money lending.
📌 Constitution • 74th Amendment
Q.17) The 74th Constitutional Amendment Act of 1992 deals with:
Ans > Municipalities (Urban Local Government)
- Parallel Urban Reform: The urban counterpart to the 73rd Amendment, aimed at establishing a uniform democratic framework for Urban Local Bodies (ULBs).
- Introduction of Part IX-A: Added Part IX-A to the Constitution, titled “The Municipalities,” encompassing Articles 243P to 243ZG.
- Curing Mismanagement: Designed to cure issues of state supersession, delayed elections, and revenue starvation by granting constitutional permanence.
- Date of Enforcement: Came into effect on June 1, 1993, mandating states to conform their municipal laws within one year.
📌 Municipalities • Schedules
Q.18) The 74th Amendment Act added Part IX-A to the Constitution and which Schedule containing 18 functional items of Municipalities?
Ans > Twelfth Schedule
- Mapping Urban Responsibilities: Introduced the Twelfth Schedule, tied to Article 243W, outlining powers and responsibilities for urban local bodies.
- 18 Functional Items: Comprehensively lists 18 distinct administrative and developmental subjects providing a blueprint for modern urban management.
- Core Infrastructure: Includes urban town planning, roads/bridges, water supply, public health, sanitation, solid waste management, and fire services.
- Social Duties: Mandates focus on urban forestry, slum improvement, poverty alleviation, and public amenities like parks and street lighting.
📌 Municipalities • Classification
Q.19) Under the 74th Amendment, a ‘Nagar Panchayat’ is constituted for a:
Ans > Transitional area (from rural to urban)
- Defining the Fringe: Designed for a “transitional area” in the active process of transforming from a rural demographic to an urban one.
- Criteria for Transition: Determined by the Governor based on population size/density, local revenue, and percentage of non-agricultural adult male employment.
- Administrative Bridge: Steps in to handle early urban pressures like paved roads and drainage before the area warrants a full municipal council.
- Structural Composition: Members are directly elected by residents; focuses on basic town planning and public health.
📌 Municipalities • Classification
Q.20) Under the 74th Amendment, a ‘Municipal Council’ is constituted for a:
Ans > Smaller urban area
- Mid-Sized Towns: Constituted for a “smaller urban area” (typically established towns and smaller cities); often called Nagar Palika.
- Governor’s Discretion: The Governor defines this classification through public notification based on population and revenue thresholds.
- Executive/Legislative Split: Legislative wing consists of elected councillors; the executive wing is often run by a state-appointed Chief Officer.
- Service Delivery Focus: Handles complex civic responsibilities like solid waste management, primary schools, urban water distribution, and road networks.
📌 Municipalities • Classification
Q.21) Under the 74th Amendment, a ‘Municipal Corporation’ is constituted for a:
Ans > Larger urban area
- Managing Metropolises: The highest tier of urban local government, specifically for a “larger urban area” (major metropolitan cities like Mumbai, Delhi).
- Legislative Origins: Frequently established by specific, standalone Acts passed by the State Legislature or Parliament rather than general municipal acts.
- Tripartite Structure: Consists of the Corporation Council (elected), Standing Committees (portfolios), and the Municipal Commissioner (chief executive).
- Immense Resource Handling: Manages colossal budgets rivaling small states, responsible for massive infrastructure, transport systems, and hospitals.
📌 Municipalities • Wards Committees
Q.22) Article 243S mandates the constitution of Wards Committees in municipalities having a population of:
Ans > 3 lakhs or more
- Decentralizing the City: Article 243S mandates Wards Committees to ensure micro-level decentralization within large, growing urban sprawls.
- Population Threshold: Must be constituted only in municipalities with a population of 3 lakhs (300,000) or more.
- Composition: Consists of one or more municipal wards grouped by proximity. The state determines territorial area and member composition.
- Local Councillors: The elected councillor for a ward serves as a direct member, creating a localized grievance redressal hub.
📌 Municipalities • Planning
Q.23) Under Article 243ZD, every state shall constitute at the district level a committee to consolidate the plans prepared by panchayats and municipalities. It is called the:
Ans > District Planning Committee
- Bridging the Divide: Created to break down planning silos by consolidating plans from both rural panchayats and urban municipalities into a cohesive vision.
- Holistic Spatial Planning: Prepares a draft development plan for the entire district involving spatial planning, water resources, and joint infrastructure.
- Democratic Composition: The Constitution mandates at least four-fifths (80%) of members be elected by/from local elected members of the district.
- Proportional Representation: Rural/urban member ratio must strictly reflect the rural/urban population ratio within that district.
📌 Municipalities • Planning
Q.24) Under Article 243ZE, every metropolitan area must have a:
Ans > Metropolitan Planning Committee
- Mega-City Complexity: Mandated for areas with a population of 10 lakhs (one million) or more spanning multiple municipalities/districts.
- Integration: Integrates development plans of overlapping local bodies, townships, and rural fringes into one master urban strategy.
- Representation: At least two-thirds of members must be elected by/from elected municipal and panchayat members, proportionate to population.
- Strategic Planning: Resolves resource conflicts, plans massive transit systems, and coordinates with specialized agencies (water boards, transport).
📌 Municipalities • History
Q.25) The first municipal corporation in India was set up in 1687 at:
Ans > Madras
- Colonial Origins: Formal municipal governance was introduced by the British East India Company, starting in Madras (Chennai) in 1687.
- Josiah Child: It was the brainchild of Sir Josiah Child to efficiently collect taxes for civic amenities and local defense.
- Initial Composition: Modeled on the English system with a Mayor, Aldermen, and Burgesses, though fiercely opposed initially by locals over taxes.
- Expansions: In 1726, a Royal Charter established similar formal Municipal Corporations in Bombay and Calcutta.
📌 Local Governance • Special Boards
Q.26) A Cantonment Board is established for municipal administration for the civilian population in the cantonment area. It works under the administrative control of the:
Ans > Union Ministry of Defence
- Unique Jurisdiction: Established specifically to administer the civilian population within permanent military stations, totally insulated from State Government control.
- Central Control: Created under the Cantonments Act of 2006 (a central law), operating directly under the Union Ministry of Defence.
- Hybrid Body: Consists of partly elected civilian members and partly nominated military members, with a centrally appointed Executive Officer.
- Military Leadership: The General Officer Commanding (GOC) or highest-ranking military officer acts as the ex-officio President of the Board.
📌 Local Governance • Special Boards
Q.27) Port Trusts are established in the port areas to manage and protect ports and provide civic amenities. They are created by:
Ans > An Act of Parliament
- Strategic Importance: Specialized urban bodies established exclusively around major commercial ports (Mumbai, Kolkata, Chennai). Managed centrally.
- Central Legislation: Created through specific Acts of Parliament (e.g., Major Port Trusts Act, 1963) ensuring uniform maritime law.
- Dual Responsibilities: Manages commercial port operations economically, while acting as a municipality providing basic amenities to port residents.
- Nominated Structure: Primarily an appointed body for efficiency. The majority are nominated by the Central Government (navy, customs, trade reps).
📌 Local Governance • Special Boards
Q.28) Which urban local body is set up by a state legislature for the administration of a small town and is a semi-municipal authority?
Ans > Town Area Committee
- Handling the Urban Fringe: Created for very small towns that do not meet the criteria for a full Municipal Council or Nagar Panchayat.
- State Legislative Authority: Entirely a creature of the State Legislature, set up under specific state acts dictating its boundaries and powers.
- Limited Civic Mandate: Duties are restricted to fundamental hygiene: street lighting, rudimentary drainage, local roads, and basic conservancy.
- Flexible Composition: Democratic makeup depends on the state; it can be wholly elected, wholly nominated, or a hybrid.
📌 Municipalities • Executive
Q.29) The chief executive authority of a Municipal Corporation, responsible for implementing the decisions of the council and its standing committees, is the:
Ans > Municipal Commissioner
- Separation of Powers: Architecture is divided between the deliberative wing (elected Mayor/Councillors) and the executive wing.
- Role of the Commissioner: Serves as the apex executive. Implements public works, prepares budgets, and runs daily civic services.
- Bureaucratic Appointment: Directly appointed by the State Government, typically a senior IAS officer for professional, detached management.
- State-City Link: Acts as a critical bridge. They execute local elected council resolutions but remain ultimately answerable to the State.
📌 Municipalities • Mayor
Q.30) The Mayor is the ornamental figurehead and formal head of a Municipal Corporation. How is he usually chosen?
Ans > Elected for a one-year renewable term
- The First Citizen: The Mayor is the formal, ceremonial head, holding high social prestige and representing the city in public ceremonies.
- Election by Peers: In most Indian states, the Mayor is elected indirectly by the directly elected municipal councillors.
- Short Tenure: Usually elected for a one-year renewable term to rotate leadership and prevent localized concentration of executive power.
- Limited Executive Power: Primary duty is presiding over Corporation Council meetings. True executive power lies with the Municipal Commissioner.
📌 Quick Summary — Polity Set 72 (Panchayati Raj & Municipalities)
- Balwant Rai Mehta (1957): Recommended the foundational 3-tier Panchayati Raj system.
- First Adoption: Rajasthan inaugurated the system on October 2, 1959, in Nagaur.
- Ashok Mehta (1977): Recommended replacing the 3-tier system with a 2-tier system.
- L.M. Singhvi (1986): Advocated strongly for constitutional status for Panchayats.
- 73rd Amendment: Added Part IX (“The Panchayats”) to the Constitution.
- 11th Schedule: Contains 29 functional items devolved to Panchayats.
- Gram Sabha: Article 243A establishes it as the foundation of direct rural democracy.
- Intermediate Tier Exemption: States with population under 20 lakhs can skip the middle tier.
- Elections: Panchayat members are elected directly; Chairpersons at higher tiers indirectly.
- Reservation: Minimum one-third of seats reserved for women at all levels.
- Tenure & Dissolution: Fixed 5-year term; elections within 6 months if dissolved prematurely.
- Minimum Age: 21 years is required to contest Panchayat elections.
- State Election Commission: Article 243K creates it to independently conduct local elections.
- State Finance Commission: Constituted every 5 years to review local body finances.
- Exemptions: Part IX excludes Nagaland, Meghalaya, Mizoram, and certain tribal areas.
- PESA Act (1996): Extends Part IX to Scheduled Areas with specific tribal autonomy modifications.
- 74th Amendment: Added Part IX-A and 12th Schedule (18 items) for Municipalities.
- Urban Classifications: Nagar Panchayat (transitional), Municipal Council (smaller area), Corporation (larger area).
- Planning Committees: DPC (District) and MPC (Metropolitan) consolidate local development plans.
- Executive & Ceremonial Heads: Commissioner holds true executive power; Mayor is a ceremonial figurehead with a typical 1-year term.
Timer ⏳
15:00
Progress (0/30)
Click any card to flip and reveal the summarized answer!
Smart Review: Questions you got wrong appear here for focused study.