Polity Set 67
π
π Polity β’ Vice-President
Q.1) Which Article of the Constitution provides for the office of the Vice-President of India?
Ans > Article 63
- Constitutional Mandate: The Constitution of India explicitly mandates the creation of this office under Article 63, which states, “There shall be a Vice-President of India.” This ensures the second-highest constitutional office remains a permanent fixture within the Union Executive.
- Order of Precedence: In the Indian democratic setup, the Vice-President occupies the second-highest office in the country. They rank strictly next to the President of India in the official warrant of precedence, highlighting the immense dignity attached to the role.
- American Inspiration: The architects of the Indian Constitution modelled the office of the Vice-President on the lines of the American Vice-President. This is visible in their shared primary function: acting as the ex-officio Chairman of their respective legislative upper houses.
π Polity β’ Vice-President
Q.2) The Vice-President is elected by an electoral college consisting of the members of both Houses of Parliament. How does this electoral college differ from that of the President?
Ans > It consists of both elected and nominated members of the Parliament.
- Inclusion of Nominated Members: Unlike the President’s election, which only permits elected parliamentarians to vote, the Vice-Presidential electoral college includes both elected and nominated members of the Rajya Sabha and the Lok Sabha, reflecting their role in the upper house.
- Exclusion of State Assemblies: The President represents both the Union and the States, hence state MLAs participate in their election. The Vice-President’s primary function is presiding over the Council of States (Rajya Sabha), meaning state MLAs do not vote in this specific election.
- Method of Election: Despite the differences in the electoral college, the election method remains identical to the President’s. It is held using the system of proportional representation by means of a single transferable vote, conducted via a secret ballot.
π Polity β’ Qualifications
Q.3) To be eligible for election as Vice-President, a person must be qualified for election as a member of the:
Ans > Rajya Sabha
- Alignment with Primary Role: The most significant regular function of the Vice-President is to act as the ex-officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha. Therefore, constitutional framers logically mandated that the candidate must possess the qualifications required to be a member of that specific house.
- Age and Citizenship Criteria: Alongside the Rajya Sabha qualification, the candidate must unequivocally be a citizen of India and have completed the age of 35 years. These foundational criteria ensure both maturity and unquestioned nationality for this high constitutional office.
- Office of Profit Restriction: A crucial qualification is that the candidate must not hold any office of profit under the Union government, state government, or any local authority. This safeguard prevents potential conflicts of interest and ensures absolute impartiality.
π Polity β’ Vice-President
Q.4) Who administers the oath of office to the Vice-President of India?
Ans > The President, or some person appointed in that behalf by him
- Constitutional Provision: According to Article 69 of the Indian Constitution, the oath of office to the Vice-President is strictly administered by the President of India. If the President is unavailable, it is administered by a person explicitly appointed by the President for this purpose.
- Content of the Oath: Before entering office, the Vice-President formally swears to bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of India and to faithfully discharge the duties of the office. This reinforces the absolute supremacy of the Indian Constitution.
- Hierarchy and Protocol: The administration of the oath by the President underscores the formal constitutional hierarchy. It reflects a structured order of precedence where the head of state inducts their immediate second-in-command, maintaining the ceremonial dignity of the Union Executive.
π Polity β’ Parliament
Q.5) A formal impeachment is NOT required for the removal of the Vice-President. He can be removed by a resolution passed by a majority of all the then members of the Rajya Sabha and agreed to by the:
Ans > Lok Sabha
- Simplified Removal Process: Unlike the President of India, who requires a complex and rigid impeachment process involving a two-thirds majority in both houses, the Vice-President can be removed through a relatively simpler legislative route without any formal impeachment trial or specified grounds.
- Rajya Sabha’s Exclusive Initiation: Because the Vice-President’s primary role is serving as the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, a resolution for their removal can only be introduced in the Rajya Sabha. It must be passed by an “effective majority” (a majority of all the then members).
- Lok Sabha’s Mandatory Consent: While initiation and an absolute majority are required in the Upper House, the Lok Sabha must also agree to this resolution. However, the Lok Sabha only needs to pass it with a simple majority (members present and voting), balancing the power between houses.
π Polity β’ Vice-President
Q.6) The Vice-President acts as the ex-officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha. In this capacity, his powers and functions are similar to those of the:
Ans > Speaker of the Lok Sabha
- Constitutional Parity in Presiding: As the ex-officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, the Vice-President holds the exact same disciplinary, procedural, and administrative powers over the Upper House as the Speaker holds over the lower house (Lok Sabha), maintaining strict parliamentary order.
- Casting Vote Authority: Similar to the Speaker of the Lok Sabha, the Vice-President does not cast a vote in the first instance during regular legislative proceedings. However, they possess a crucial casting vote to break a tie, ensuring legislative gridlocks are effectively resolved.
- Financial Entitlements: When acting as the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, the Vice-President draws the regular salary and allowances assigned specifically to the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, rather than a separate Vice-Presidential salary, drawing a direct parallel to the Speaker’s financial framework.
π Polity β’ Vice-President
Q.7) For what maximum period can the Vice-President act as the President when a vacancy occurs in the office of the President?
Ans > Six months
- Constitutional Time Limit: Article 62 of the Constitution mandates that an election to fill a vacancy in the office of the President (due to death, resignation, or removal) must be held in no case later than six months from the date the vacancy occurred.
- Difference from the US System: This is a major departure from the American political system. In the USA, if the presidency falls vacant, the Vice-President assumes the office for the entire unexpired remainder of the term, whereas in India, it is only a temporary stopgap.
- Transfer of Privileges: During this maximum six-month period when acting as President, the Vice-President is entitled to all the powers, immunities, privileges, and emoluments of the President, and simultaneously ceases to perform the duties of the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha.
π Polity β’ Prime Minister
Q.8) According to Article 75, the Prime Minister shall be appointed by the:
Ans > President
- Formal Executive Action: Article 75 strictly stipulates that the Prime Minister shall be appointed by the President. This is a formal executive action that legally empowers the leader of the majority party or coalition to form the Union government.
- Discretionary Power Constraints: While the President makes the appointment, they do not have absolute discretion. According to established parliamentary conventions, the President is bound to invite the leader of the political party that commands an absolute majority in the Lok Sabha.
- Situational Discretion: The President exercises genuine personal discretion only when no single party secures a clear absolute majority in the Lok Sabha. In such hung parliament scenarios, the President usually appoints the leader of the largest single party or coalition and asks them to prove a vote of confidence.
π Polity β’ Appointments
Q.9) Does the Constitution require that a person must prove his majority in the Lok Sabha BEFORE he is appointed as Prime Minister?
Ans > No, the President may first appoint him and then ask him to prove his majority within a reasonable period.
- Judicial Validation: In 1980, the Delhi High Court explicitly ruled that the Constitution does not require a person to prove their majority in the Lok Sabha prior to being appointed as Prime Minister. The President has the authority to make the appointment first.
- Reasonable Timeframe: Following the appointment, the President directs the newly appointed Prime Minister to prove their majority on the floor of the House within a “reasonable period.” This ensures that the executive branch functions without a vacuum while parliamentary strength is tested.
- Historical Precedents: This constitutional mechanism has been utilized multiple times in Indian political history. A prominent example occurred in 1979 when President Neelam Sanjiva Reddy appointed Charan Singh as Prime Minister and subsequently asked him to seek a vote of confidence in the Lok Sabha.
π Polity β’ Qualifications
Q.10) Can a person who is NOT a member of either House of Parliament be appointed as Prime Minister?
Ans > Yes, for six months, within which he should become a member of either House.
- Constitutional Flexibility: Article 75(5) of the Constitution allows for incredible flexibility by permitting a person who is not a Member of Parliament (MP) to be appointed as a Minister, which includes the office of the Prime Minister, for a strictly limited grace period.
- Six-Month Deadline: The absolute deadline for this arrangement is six consecutive months. If the appointed Prime Minister fails to get elected to either the Lok Sabha or the Rajya Sabha within this exact timeframe, they automatically cease to be a minister.
- Real-World Application: This unique provision is not just theoretical; it has been applied in reality. In 1996, H.D. Deve Gowda was appointed as the Prime Minister of India despite not being a member of either house at the exact time of his swearing-in ceremony.
π Polity β’ Prime Minister
Q.11) The term of the Prime Minister is not fixed and he holds office during the pleasure of the President. However, the President cannot dismiss him as long as he enjoys majority support in the:
Ans > Lok Sabha
- Parliamentary Democracy Principle: The bedrock of India’s parliamentary democracy is that the executive is ultimately responsible to the popular lower house. The Prime Minister derives their actual authority and mandate exclusively from commanding a majority in the directly elected Lok Sabha.
- Meaning of “Pleasure”: The phrase “during the pleasure of the President” does not grant the President dictatorial power to fire the Prime Minister arbitrarily. It is a constitutional formality. The “pleasure” legally translates to the Prime Minister retaining the confidence of the Lok Sabha.
- Dismissal Conditions: The President can only dismiss the Prime Minister if they lose a no-confidence motion in the Lok Sabha and subsequently refuse to resign. As long as the majority support is intact, the Prime Minister’s position is completely secure from presidential dismissal.
π Polity β’ Committees
Q.12) The Prime Minister is the ex-officio Chairman of which of the following bodies?
Ans > All of the above
- Policy and Planning Leadership: As the head of government, the Prime Minister naturally chairs NITI Aayog (formerly the Planning Commission). This ensures that the nation’s premier public policy think tank aligns its strategies directly with the top executive’s developmental vision.
- National Unity Oversight: The Prime Minister chairs the National Integration Council, a body specifically constituted to find ways to tackle the evils of communalism, casteism, regionalism, and linguistic chauvinism, emphasizing the PM’s role as a unifying national figure.
- Federal Dispute Resolution: By chairing the Inter-State Council (established under Article 263), the Prime Minister acts as the supreme mediator in India’s federal structure, helping to investigate and advise upon disputes that may arise between various states or the Union and states.
π Polity β’ Council of Ministers
Q.13) Which Article of the Constitution states that “there shall be a Council of Ministers with the Prime Minister at the head to aid and advise the President”?
Ans > Article 74
- Core of the Cabinet System: Article 74 is the foundational pillar of the parliamentary system of government in India. It legally establishes the existence of the Council of Ministers and cements the Prime Minister’s position as its absolute head and driving force.
- Binding Nature of Advice: The phrase “aid and advise” is slightly misleading in plain English. Following the 42nd and 44th Constitutional Amendment Acts, it has been made legally clear that the President is bound to act in accordance with this advice in the exercise of their functions.
- Shielded from Courts: A crucial subset of this article (Article 74(2)) protects the executive decision-making process by stating that the question of whether any, and if so what, advice was tendered by Ministers to the President shall not be inquired into by any court.
π Polity β’ Constitutional Amendments
Q.14) The 44th Amendment Act (1978) added a proviso to Article 74 stating that the President can require the Council of Ministers to reconsider such advice, but the President:
Ans > Shall act in accordance with the advice tendered after such reconsideration
- Restoring Democratic Balance: The 44th Amendment was enacted post-Emergency to restore certain checks and balances. The previous 42nd Amendment had made cabinet advice absolutely and instantly binding on the President without any room for presidential dissent or caution.
- The Suspensive Veto: This amendment introduced a “suspensive veto” for the President. It allows the head of state to send back advice to the Council of Ministers for reconsideration if they feel a decision is hasty, unconstitutional, or not in the broader national interest.
- Ultimate Executive Supremacy: Despite granting this reconsideration power, the amendment ensured the elected government remains supreme. If the Council of Ministers sends the exact same advice back to the President after reconsidering it, the President has no choice but to sign and accept it.
π Polity β’ Accountability
Q.15) Article 75 states that the Council of Ministers shall be collectively responsible to the:
Ans > House of the People (Lok Sabha)
- The “Swim and Sink Together” Principle: Collective responsibility is the fundamental principle working behind the parliamentary system. It means that all ministers own joint responsibility to the Lok Sabha for every act of omission and commission by the government. They swim and sink together.
- Impact of a No-Confidence Motion: If the Lok Sabha passes a strictly worded no-confidence motion against the Council of Ministers, all ministers must immediately resign. This includes ministers who are members of the Rajya Sabha; they are not exempt from this collective fall.
- Cabinet Solidarity: This principle enforces strict cabinet solidarity. Once a decision is made by the cabinet, it is the absolute duty of every single minister to stand by it and support it both inside and outside the Parliament, regardless of their personal disagreements.
π Polity β’ Amendments
Q.16) The 91st Constitutional Amendment Act of 2003 provided that the total number of ministers, including the Prime Minister, in the Council of Ministers shall not exceed what percentage of the total strength of the Lok Sabha?
Ans > 15%
- Curbing Jumbo Cabinets: The 91st Constitutional Amendment Act was introduced primarily to prevent the formation of excessively large “jumbo cabinets.” Prior to this, governments often appointed numerous ministers simply to appease political allies or disgruntled legislators, causing a massive drain on public funds.
- Specific Limitation Rule: The amendment introduced Article 75(1A), explicitly codifying that the total number of Ministers, including the Prime Minister, in the Union Council of Ministers shall never exceed 15% of the total number of members of the House of the People.
- Impact on State Governments: This 15% cap was simultaneously applied to State Governments through Article 164(1A). It mandated that state cabinets also cannot exceed 15% of the State Legislative Assembly’s strength, though it smartly provided a minimum floor limit of 12 ministers for smaller states.
π Polity β’ Cabinet Solidarity
Q.17) If a minister disagrees with a cabinet decision and is not prepared to defend it, what is he expected to do according to the principle of collective responsibility?
Ans > Resign
- Enforcing Cabinet Solidarity: The principle of collective responsibility demands a united front. The government must speak with a single, unified voice. If a minister fundamentally disagrees with a major cabinet policy, they cannot remain in the government and voice dissent simultaneously.
- Historical Resignations: Indian political history is replete with examples of principled resignations over policy differences. Dr. B.R. Ambedkar famously resigned from the cabinet due to profound differences over the passage of the Hindu Code Bill, upholding this exact parliamentary convention.
- Prevention of Internal Sabotage: This rule prevents ministers from actively working against their own government’s stated goals from within. If a minister voted against a cabinet decision in Parliament, it would indicate a spectacular breakdown of the executive branch and trigger a government crisis.
π Polity β’ Ministers
Q.18) The principle of individual responsibility is also enshrined in Article 75. It states that the ministers hold office during the pleasure of the:
Ans > President
- Constitutional Provision: Article 75(2) explicitly states that ministers shall hold office during the pleasure of the President. This establishes the principle of individual responsibility, running parallel to the collective responsibility owed directly to the Lok Sabha.
- Prime Ministerial Control: While legally they hold office during the President’s pleasure, practically, this power is exercised entirely on the binding advice of the Prime Minister. The PM has the absolute authority to ask any minister to resign at any time.
- Mechanism for Removal: If a minister refuses a direct request to resign from the Prime Minister, the PM can advise the President to formally dismiss that specific minister. This ensures the PM retains total control over the composition and discipline of their cabinet.
π Polity β’ Legal Responsibility
Q.19) Unlike in Britain, the Indian Constitution does NOT provide for a system of legal responsibility of a minister. Therefore, an order of the President for a public act:
Ans > Does not require the countersignature of a minister
- Departure from Westminster: In the British political system, every order of the Crown requires the countersignature of a minister, who then assumes legal liability for that act in court. The Indian Constitution specifically did not adopt this system of individual legal liability.
- Protection of Executive Orders: In India, an order issued in the name of the President does not require a minister’s countersignature to be legally valid. The courts are actively barred from questioning the nature of the advice tendered by ministers to the President.
- Focus on Political Responsibility: The framers of the Indian Constitution intentionally prioritized political responsibility (to the Parliament and the electorate) over legal responsibility, ensuring that ministers answer for their policies in the legislature rather than facing constant litigation for executive orders.
π Polity β’ Council of Ministers
Q.20) The Council of Ministers consists of three categories of ministers. Which of the following is NOT one of those categories?
Ans > Kitchen Ministers
- Three-Tier Formal Structure: The formal, official structure of the Council of Ministers is strictly divided into three distinct ranks: Cabinet Ministers (the highest), Ministers of State (middle rank), and Deputy Ministers (the lowest formal rank), each with differing pay, privileges, and responsibilities.
- Cabinet Ministers’ Role: Cabinet Ministers are the senior-most politicians who head major, critical ministries like Home, Defence, Finance, and External Affairs. They are the only ministers who have the inherent right to attend all cabinet meetings and participate in core policy formulation.
- Informality of the “Kitchen”: A “Kitchen Cabinet” is entirely an informal, extra-constitutional term used by political analysts. It refers to a small, close-knit circle of trusted advisors to the Prime Minister, but it is not an official category or rank recognized by the Indian Constitution.
π Polity β’ The Cabinet
Q.21) Which body is a smaller body consisting of 15 to 20 important ministers and is the real centre of authority in the state politico-administrative system?
Ans > The Cabinet
- The Nucleus of Power: While the Council of Ministers is a large body (often 60 to 70 ministers), the actual Cabinet is a much smaller, elite subgroup of 15 to 20 senior ministers. It functions as the highest decision-making authority in the Indian politico-administrative system.
- Policy Formulation Engine: The Cabinet is the chief policy-formulating body of the Central government. It directs the implementation of major government policies, handles vital foreign affairs, and resolves inter-departmental disputes, acting as the supreme steering committee for the entire nation.
- Advising the President: When the Constitution states that the President acts on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers, in practical, everyday reality, it is the advice formulated specifically by this smaller Cabinet that is transmitted to the head of state.
π Polity β’ Cabinet Committees
Q.22) Cabinet Committees are extra-constitutional in emergence. They are established by the:
Ans > Rules of Business
- Extra-Constitutional Nature: Cabinet Committees are not mentioned anywhere in the main text of the Indian Constitution. They are entirely extra-constitutional devices created to reduce the enormous workload of the Cabinet and facilitate in-depth policy examinations.
- Legal Foundation: Their legal foundation stems from the Government of India Transaction of Business Rules, 1961. These rules allow for the creation of standing and ad hoc committees to streamline complex administrative and political decision-making processes efficiently.
- Flexibility and Adaptation: Because they are based on rules of business rather than constitutional amendments, the number, nomenclature, and composition of Cabinet Committees can be easily modified by the Prime Minister to suit the exigencies of the time and the specific requirements of the current administration.
π Polity β’ Cabinet Committees
Q.23) Cabinet Committees are of two types: standing and ad hoc. The ad hoc committees are constituted:
Ans > To deal with special problems on a temporary basis
- Temporary Problem Solvers: While standing committees are permanent fixtures designed to handle continuous domains like economic affairs or security, ad hoc committees are strictly temporary mechanisms constituted from time to time to deal with very specific, emergent, or specialized problems.
- Automatic Dissolution: The defining characteristic of an ad hoc committee is its lifecycle. Once the specific task it was formed to address is completed and its final report or recommendations are submitted to the main Cabinet, the committee is automatically disbanded.
- Historical Examples: Governments frequently set up ad hoc committees to handle immediate crises, investigate major scams, frame initial drafts for highly complex legislation, or manage logistical nightmares during large-scale national emergencies where a focused, temporary group of ministers is required.
π Polity β’ Super-Cabinet
Q.24) Of all the Cabinet Committees, which one is the most powerful and is often described as a “Super-Cabinet”?
Ans > Political Affairs Committee
- The Supreme Arbiter: The Political Affairs Committee stands undeniably at the apex of the committee hierarchy. Because it deals with all major domestic and foreign policy issuesβthe most sensitive aspects of governanceβit is universally regarded as the most powerful committee.
- The “Super-Cabinet” Moniker: It is frequently described by political analysts as a “Super-Cabinet” because its decisions are rarely overturned by the full Cabinet. It essentially functions as a concentrated, high-powered version of the main Cabinet, handling the most explosive political crises.
- Broad Jurisdiction: Its sweeping jurisdiction covers everything from Centre-State relations and border disputes to broad foreign policy directives and national security strategies, making it the central nervous system of the government’s political decision-making apparatus.
π Polity β’ Committee Leadership
Q.25) Who invariably acts as the Chairman of the Political Affairs Committee, the Economic Affairs Committee, and the Appointments Committee?
Ans > The Prime Minister
- Consolidation of Executive Power: The Prime Minister invariably chairs the three most critical standing committees: Political Affairs, Economic Affairs, and the Appointments Committee. This ensures the PM maintains an iron grip on the most crucial levers of government policy and personnel.
- Appointments Authority: By chairing the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet (ACC), the Prime Minister directly controls all top-level bureaucratic, military, and public sector appointments, from RBI Governors to Defence Chiefs, solidifying their dominance over the administrative machinery.
- Economic Stewardship: Chairing the Economic Affairs Committee allows the Prime Minister to personally steer the macroeconomic trajectory of the country, oversee crucial investment clearances, and manage supply-side policies without leaving these entirely to the Finance Ministry.
π Polity β’ Parliamentary Affairs
Q.26) The Parliamentary Affairs Committee, which looks after the progress of government business in the Parliament, is usually headed by the:
Ans > The Home Minister
- Delegation of Legislative Management: While the Prime Minister heavily dominates the other major policy committees, the complex, day-to-day management of government business within the Parliament is traditionally delegated to a highly trusted senior colleague, almost always the Union Home Minister.
- Scope of Responsibilities: This committee is responsible for drawing up the schedule for legislative bills, monitoring the progress of government business in both houses, and strategizing floor management to ensure bills pass without political embarrassment or sudden defeats.
- Coordination Role: The Home Minister, acting as chairman, coordinates closely with the Minister of Parliamentary Affairs, party whips, and allied political parties to maintain quorum, manage aggressive opposition tactics, and ensure smooth legislative functioning during intense parliamentary sessions.
π Polity β’ Prime Minister Duties
Q.27) Article 78 outlines the duties of the Prime Minister. One of these duties is to communicate to the President:
Ans > All decisions of the Council of Ministers relating to the administration of the affairs of the Union and proposals for legislation
- Constitutional Bridge: Article 78 legally codifies the Prime Minister’s duty to act as the primary constitutional bridge between the active executive (the Council of Ministers) and the formal head of state (the President), ensuring the President is never kept in the dark.
- Mandatory Information Flow: It is a strict constitutional obligation for the Prime Minister to proactively communicate all administrative decisions and pending legislative proposals. The President does not have to hunt for this information; the Prime Minister must deliver it regularly.
- Presidential Right to Know: The same article also grants the President the explicit right to call for any specific information relating to the administration of the Union’s affairs. If the President asks, the Prime Minister is constitutionally bound to furnish those details promptly.
π Polity β’ Executive Communication
Q.28) Who is the principal channel of communication between the President and the Council of Ministers?
Ans > The Prime Minister
- Exclusive Conduit: Under the framework established by Article 78, the Prime Minister acts as the sole, exclusive, and principal channel of formal communication between the President of India and the vast machinery of the Council of Ministers.
- Preventing Miscommunication: This singular conduit system is designed to prevent conflicting reports or scattered advice from reaching the President. By routing all official cabinet communications through the PM, the government ensures a unified, coherent message is presented to the head of state.
- Individual Minister Constraint: Individual ministers are generally discouraged from bypassing the Prime Minister to discuss major policy issues directly with the President, unless the PM specifically authorizes it or the President exercises their right to require a matter to be submitted to the full council.
π Polity β’ PM’s Advisory Role
Q.29) The Prime Minister advises the President with regard to the appointment of important officials. Which of the following is NOT typically included in this list?
Ans > Chief Ministers of States
- State-Level Autonomy: India’s federal structure mandates that Chief Ministers are appointed by the Governors of their respective states under Article 164 of the Constitution. This happens completely outside the purview of the President or the Prime Minister’s advisory scope.
- Union Executive Appointments: The Prime Minister’s advisory power is immense but restricted to Union-level constitutional authorities. They actively advise the President on appointing the Attorney General (the government’s chief legal advisor) and the Comptroller and Auditor General (the supreme audit authority).
- Commission Appointments: The Prime Minister also plays the decisive role in advising the President on the appointments of the Chairman and members of key central bodies like the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC), the Election Commission, and the Finance Commission.
π Polity β’ The Kitchen Cabinet
Q.30) An informal body consisting of the Prime Minister and two to four influential colleagues in whom he has faith, which advises him on important political and administrative issues, is popularly known as the:
Ans > Kitchen Cabinet (Inner Cabinet)
- Extra-Constitutional Phenomenon: The “Kitchen Cabinet” or “Inner Cabinet” is a highly informal, extra-constitutional phenomenon. It is not mentioned in any official rulebook, yet it frequently operates as the most crucial, fast-acting decision-making nucleus within any government.
- Composition Based on Trust: Unlike formal committees based on seniority or ministerial portfolios, this body is comprised purely of individuals the Prime Minister trusts implicitly. It often includes two to four key cabinet ministers, but can occasionally include trusted friends, family members, or powerful external advisors.
- Efficiency vs. Transparency: Prime Ministers rely heavily on this inner circle because it allows for rapid, confidential, and frank decision-making, completely bypassing the bureaucratic hurdles of full cabinet meetings. However, political critics often argue it undermines collective responsibility and transparency.
π Quick Summary β Polity Set 67
- Vice-President Office: Mandated by Article 63, inspired by the American VP system.
- Electoral College (VP): Consists of both elected and nominated members of Parliament.
- Qualification for VP: Must be qualified for election as a member of the Rajya Sabha.
- Oath of VP: Administered by the President or a person appointed by him.
- Removal of VP: Requires a resolution passed by Rajya Sabha and agreed to by Lok Sabha.
- Ex-officio Role: VP acts as Chairman of Rajya Sabha (powers similar to Lok Sabha Speaker).
- Acting President: VP can act as President for a maximum period of six months.
- Prime Minister Appointment: The PM is formally appointed by the President (Article 75).
- Proving Majority: Can be appointed first, and asked to prove majority within a reasonable period.
- Non-MP as PM: A non-MP can be appointed as PM for a maximum of six months.
- Term of PM: Holds office during pleasure of the President, but secure as long as they enjoy Lok Sabha majority.
- Ex-officio PM Roles: Chairman of NITI Aayog, National Integration Council, Inter-State Council.
- Aid and Advise: Article 74 mandates a Council of Ministers with PM at head to advise President.
- Reconsideration of Advice: The 44th Amendment allows the President to send back advice once.
- Collective Responsibility: Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha.
- Ministerial Cap: 91st Amendment capped the Council of Ministers size to 15% of the Lok Sabha.
- Cabinet Disagreement: A minister must resign if they disagree with and cannot defend a cabinet decision.
- Individual Responsibility: Ministers hold office during the pleasure of the President.
- No Legal Responsibility: Presidential orders in India do not require a minister’s countersignature.
- Categories of Ministers: Cabinet Ministers, Ministers of State, and Deputy Ministers.
- The Cabinet: A smaller elite group of 15-20 ministers that is the real centre of authority.
- Cabinet Committees: Extra-constitutional bodies established by the Rules of Business.
- Ad hoc Committees: Formed strictly to deal with special, temporary problems.
- Super-Cabinet: The Political Affairs Committee is the most powerful committee.
- PM’s Chairmanship: PM invariably chairs the Political, Economic, and Appointments Committees.
- Parliamentary Affairs: The Parliamentary Affairs Committee is usually headed by the Home Minister.
- Article 78 Duties: PM must communicate all Cabinet decisions relating to administration and legislation.
- Channel of Communication: The PM is the principal conduit between the President and the Council.
- PM Advisory Exemptions: PM does not advise the President on the appointment of State Chief Ministers.
- Kitchen Cabinet: An informal, highly influential advisory group of trusted colleagues to the PM.
Timer β³
15:00
Progress (0/30)
Click any card to flip and reveal the summarized answer!
Smart Review: Questions you got wrong appear here for focused study.